Is “Rude” By Magic The Worst #1 Song Of All Time

A music critic for the NY Post is calling "Rude" one of the worst #1 songs ever.

Hardeep Phull writes - “Rude” is just awful, a flaccid, boring slice of lightweight reggae that sounds like it was written to be heard in a dentist’s waiting room."

Ouch.

I like the song.  Most of the people I've talked to like it.  Is this critic a "too cool for the room d-bag" or does he have a point?