For those not lucky enough to be in the know, Trader Joe's is a popular American chain of neighborhood grocery stores known for its unique selection of products, emphasis on value, and loyal customers in the communities that it's in.

There are currently three Trader Joe's stores in Wisconsin: one in Madison, one in Milwaukee, and one in Brookfield. A new store is also planned to open in Madison in December.

Now is the time when customers enjoy seasonal favorites arriving. With all the new fall arrivals to choose from at Trader Joe's, it can be tough to pick a favorite, but a recent study determined what the most popular fall item is for people in Wisconsin.

The Most Popular Fall Trader Joe's Products In America

JoyBird recently decided to find the most popular Trader Joe's products across the country. To accomplish this, they compiled a list of 98 seasonal products from Trader Joe’s official fall collection.

Then, using Google Trends, they analyzed relative search interest for each item across all 50 states. The most searched item in each state was identified, and products were then ranked by the number of states they dominated to reveal both regional favorites and nationwide trends.

After analyzing all the data, the following were the top fall products in the country:

  • Pumpkin Butter: A smooth, spiced spread made from pumpkin purée, sugar, and warm spices like cinnamon and nutmeg.
  • Pumpkin Loaf: A sweet, moist quick bread flavored with pumpkin and fall spices, sold pre-baked and ready to slice.
  • Pumpkin Bagels: Seasonal bagels made with pumpkin purée and pumpkin spice flavoring, perfect for fall breakfasts.
  • Halloween Gummies: Fruit-flavored gummy candies shaped like bats, pumpkins, and other Halloween icons.
  • Pumpkin Overnight Oats: A ready-to-eat breakfast cup made with rolled oats, pumpkin purée, and spices.
  • Savory Squash Pastry Bites: A frozen appetizer of puff pastry filled with a savory squash blend and creamy cheeses.
  • Gluten Free Cornbread Mix: A seasonal baking mix for making cornbread without wheat flour, offering a fall-friendly comfort food option.
  • Apple Cider Donuts: Cake-style donuts flavored with apple cider and coated in cinnamon sugar, similar to orchard and farm stand treats. They were the favorite in New Hampshire.

SEE NOW: New Canadian Pacific Holiday Train Schedule Includes 13 Stops In Wisconsin

While they all sound delicious, people in Wisconsin have a definite favorite, and it appears they love to start their day with Trader Joe's.

The Top Fall Trader Joe's Product In Wisconsin

The top fall product in Wisconsin was also the top choice for people in Colorado and Michigan. The winner was the Pumpkin Overnight Oats. I think that while it's made to be a breakfast item, it would be a good snack any time of the day. Then, why not try all Trader Joe's fall products while you can?

When You Can Expect The First Snow in 10 Cities Across Wisconsin

Curious when you typically see the first measurable snowfall in your Wisconsin city? Here's a great place to start, courtesy of ChatGPT.

Gallery Credit: Lauren Wells

This Wisconsin Mansion For Sale Looks Like a Real-Life Castle

Every inch of this home is packed with personality and history. Get ready to scroll with awe and likely a little jealousy for whoever is lucky enough to live in this picture-perfect mansion!

Gallery Credit: Samm Adams

More From 106.9 KROC-FM